020 7224 4622info@thenaturaldoctor.org
The Natural Doctor
The Natural Doctor
logo
  • HOME
  • ABOUT
    • About Dr. Nyjon Eccles
    • About Dr. Anna Forbes
    • Our Philosophy
    • Referral Scheme
  • SERVICES
    • Women
      • Bioidentical Hormone Replacement for Women
      • Menopause Treatment
      • Breast Thermography
      • Breast Nutricheck
      • Fertility Improvement
      • BioJeune™ Face Rejuvenation
      • BioGroHair® Restoration For Women
      • Bio ‘O’™ Libido Enhancement
    • Men
      • Bioidentical Hormone Replacement For Men
      • Recharge Program For Men
      • BioGroHair® Restoration Consultations
      • Bio ‘O’™ Libido Enhancement
    • Cancer Patient Support
    • Autism Support
  • BREAST HEALTH CLINIC
    • Breast Thermography
    • Breast Health Consultations
    • Breast Nutricheck
  • MEDIA/ARTICLES
    • Scientific Articles
    • Blog
    • Videos
    • Podcasts
    • Press
    • Testimonials
      • Breast Health
      • Cancer Patient Support
      • Hormones
      • Hair Restoration
      • General
    • Research
  • FEES
  • SHOP
  • CONTACT
    • Find Us
    • Make an Enquiry
  •  
Good Breast Health Needs More Than An Nhs Audit

Good breast health needs more than an NHS audit, By Dr. EcclesBlog


Avatar for The Natural Doctor
09 Nov 2018 by Dr. Nyjon Eccles in Breast Health

Breast cancer awareness month comes to a close now with the news that the National Audit Office is to investigate the four key adult health monitoring programmes offered by Public Health England and the NHS.

 The investigation follows on from the revelation earlier this year that up to 450,000 women missed routine breast screening check-ups because of a computer malfunction that dated back to 2009.

The scandal came to light in June this year and, according to then-Health Secretary Jeremy Hunt, may have contributed to the deaths of between 130 and 270 women.

National Audit Office (NAO) told Public Health England (PHE) earlier this month that it would be investigating the efficiency, effectiveness and economy of screening for breast, cervical and bowel cancers as well as routine checks for abdominal aneurysms, which pose greatest risk to those over the age of 50.

When respected health publication the Health Service Journal discovered an investigation had been agreed, it contacted PHE for comment. According to the journal, PHE initially denied an investigation was to be carried out, changing its position only when editorial staff presented evidence to the contrary.

What emerges from the detail is that of the 47 records requested by the NAO, 20 relate to breast cancer screening alone. No other screening service was singled out in the same way.

The clear inference here must be that the NAO is unconvinced that the IT infrastructure supporting NHS screening programmes is robust and resilient enough and that the same fragility may exist in other screening programmes.

In many ways, this investigation is to be welcomed. But I’d argue that it has to be more than just an assessment of IT capability. Knowing that the right individuals will be invited for screening isn’t enough to safeguard health – particularly when it comes to breast health and particularly when the screening tool of choice is mammography.

Read back through our blog archive and you’ll see plenty of argument – and, crucially, evidence – from me about the futility of mammography as an effective indicator of either cancer or breast health overall. Furthermore, Professor Peter Gøtzsche, of the Cochrane Foundation states in a summary paper that one of the best ways to reduce breast cancer is to stop mammography screening. His statement is made in particular on the basis of mammography leading to overtreatment of non –life threatening breast cancers.

Without retracing a well-worn path, it’s enough for me to say that mammography doesn’t work as it is intended. It’s employed far too late in life to be useful in managing ongoing breast health, is too late detection to be useful as an indicator of a present cancer and leads to over-treatment. It is also less useful in screening younger women because of greater breast tissue density. A normal mammogram does not mean that a woman has healthy breast tissue; only that no detectable lesion exists.

The NAO is mandated to satisfy itself on a number of different issues, one of which is the effectiveness of the screening protocol in question. We already know, through the range and scope of the IT failure, that mammography is not efficient, though that could conceivably be remedied, and may of course already have been addressed.

It seems to me, though, that it would be impossible to review mammography screening and not conclude that its effectiveness is highly questionable.

And if mammography is not effective, then it’s surely impossible to argue that it’s economical in the true sense of the word.

If proof were needed of this, we need only look back five years to a study into the cost efficiency of mammography by Paul Pharoah, a professor of cancer epidemiology, which concluded that there was only a moderate case to be made for the service’s cost efficiency. The study, reported by the British Medical Journal, also added that further studies would be needed to more accurately determine its value on an ongoing basis.

What does all this then mean?

Well, first that the NAO investigation into the adult health screening programmes must be much more than a simple box-ticking exercise in data collection. If what we end up with is a spreadsheet of data and no further meaningful action or recommendation, then the investigation itself will have been a waste of time.

And if further action is recommended, as we must hope it will be, then PHE must be seen to act on it. What that means in reality is uncertain, but at the very least there needs to be a commitment to better communication with women over the other screening options that are available to them.

By working in partnership with private clinics such as ours and making technology like our ThermoCheck® breast thermography screening available to all adult women from the age of 18 up, we can have better breast health outcomes generally.

The accuracy of new technology in identifying health risk and the opportunity it gives for early and effective intervention would lead to a reduction in cancer diagnoses and improved prevention for other breast-related conditions.

Whether or not PHE and the NHS chooses to take advantage of the opportunity to improve screening in this way – or whether the NAO forces a move toward greater transparency – remains to be seen.

But doing nothing is not an option.

BOOK AN APPOINTMENTFEES
0
Recommend
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • LinkedIN
  • Pinterest
Share
Tagged in

Contact Us

    Recent Post

    We’re having the wrong conversation about breast cancer prevention
    We’re having the wrong conversation about breast cancer prevention
    Dr. Nyjon Eccles
    Why the HRT Taskforce has failed all women
    Why the HRT Taskforce has failed all women
    Dr. Nyjon Eccles
    Why bioidentical hormone replacement therapy could save lives
    Why bioidentical hormone replacement therapy could save lives
    Dr. Nyjon Eccles
    Why we need an alternative to mammography for breast cancer screening
    Why we need an alternative to mammography for breast cancer screening
    Dr. Nyjon Eccles
    Testimonial from Jennie
    Testimonial from Jennie
    Dr. Nyjon Eccles

    Follow us

    NAVIGATE

    • About
    • Services
    • Testimonials
    • Recent Articles
    • Contact Us
    • Privacy
    • T&Cs
    Google Rating
    4.9
    The Natural Doctor
    The Natural Doctor
    4.9
    Ros
    Ros
    16:57 08 Feb 20
    I had some treatment for a breast condition in the clinic, people are very polite and nice including the doctors. I had to stop the treatment as It was not working but that's fair enough as no everything works for everybody. I stop going to the clinic and nobody in the clinic contacted me to find out what was going on, what happened with me. That showsed lack of care and I was disappointed about that.
    Alison Kittle
    Alison Kittle
    14:33 14 Aug 19
    Been visiting this clinic for nearly 10 years. It reassures me about my breast health and if I raise any concerns they are always answered well. Staff are professional but friendly. Dr Eccles knows his field. Will keep returning for my check ups. Peace of mind is worth so much.
    maria
    maria
    13:27 16 Jul 19
    For several years I have been seeing Dc Eccles for general l wellbeing. After I started seeing him, I felt much better. Excellent Doctor with very good supplements and product. I highly recommend Dr Eccles and his prescription.
    Anwen Pragnell
    Anwen Pragnell
    14:50 20 Jun 19
    A recent breast health scare in my 30's lead me to seek a less invasive option to check breast health. The Thermocheck scan, detailed report and Skype consultation with Dr Eccles was very professional and reassuring. I now feel more informed and supported in preparation for my hospital appointment. I highly recommend Dr Eccles and his team to provide an efficient, professional service and support your health naturally.
    Arthur Moore
    Arthur Moore
    09:27 16 Jan 18
    Thank you for giving me the opportunity to use your excellent product. Although it has only been 2 weeks, both myself and my wife have noticed, the hair growth has certainly become thicker, more of a covering. This is very encouraging, following many years of not really being bothered about my hair loss, now that I am noticing an improvement I am very excited at the prospects of once again having a full head of hair.
    Victoria Harris
    Victoria Harris
    09:54 12 Aug 20
    A very friendly but professional service. Experts in their field that go over and above to ensure you have the best service and experience.Highly recommend.
    Janie Wolf
    Janie Wolf
    09:06 31 May 22
    Dr Eccles has given me my life back, because he has balanced my hormones in a way that enables me to live my life to the full again!I was not only suffering with menopause fatigue and the many other symptoms of menopause, but I had ongoing lethargy with Auto-Immune Hashimotos and a struggling thyroid. It came to the point I didn’t know which symptom was due to which hormone deficiency.After my second thorough consultation with Dr Eccles, he had tweaked my dose and found I was indeed Iodine deficient. Now I am beginning to have normal levels of energy again and it is getting better and better, for the first time in five years! I sleep like a baby and my overactive bladder has been calmed. I am so glad I found Dr Eccles, life is too short to suffer with debilitating symptoms, he is the best doctor for me!
    Muxloe Property
    Muxloe Property
    19:48 17 Jun 22
    The Dr helped me feel like myself again after lots of low level symptoms. My GP dismissed me. It was worth every penny. Thank you
    Nicky Emlick
    Nicky Emlick
    21:19 23 Feb 22
    Highly recommend this practice. My experience so far after taking the thermogenic breast scan, and Bio identical hormone replacements has been a very pleasant and informative process.
    Crazy T
    Crazy T
    10:06 27 Oct 21
    I started seeing Dr Eccles almost 3 years ago for fertility issue , after struggling for 9 years and 2 miscarriages 2 years a part .I had done blood test with them and was on natural hormonal medication for almost 2 years ,and it worked for me and i fell pregnant and i have a 5 month old son now .I am still seeing him for general health and hopefully working towards second pregnancy.He is amazing , listens to every concern and answer all queries very nicely and in friendly manner and girls at receptions are also great and quick at responding to any questions or concerns i might have.
    Kelly Hafner
    Kelly Hafner
    15:58 09 Sep 21
    I began to see Dr Eccles six years ago and he continues to provide excellent care and attention every time I see him. I have referred several friends to him and they have all been very happy. Both Dr Eccles and his staff genuinely care and always go the extra mile. I highly recommend him for all areas of female health, immunity and healthy ageing in general!
    See All Reviews
    powered by Google

    FOLLOW

    SIGN UP

    © 2023 All Rights Reserved. The Natural Doctor is a Limited Company. Company Reg. No: 07360121. VAT No: GB282855959 | website by FOME

    The Natural Doctor
    Go to mobile version
    BOOK ONLINE