020 7224 4622info@thenaturaldoctor.org
The Natural Doctor
The Natural Doctor
logo
  • HOME
  • ABOUT
    • About Dr. Nyjon Eccles
    • About Dr. Anna Forbes
    • Our Philosophy
    • Referral Scheme
  • SERVICES
    • Women
      • Bioidentical Hormone Replacement for Women
      • Menopause Treatment
      • Breast Thermography
      • Breast Nutricheck
      • Fertility Improvement
      • BioJeune™ Face Rejuvenation
      • BioGroHair® Restoration For Women
      • Bio ‘O’™ Libido Enhancement
    • Men
      • Bioidentical Hormone Replacement For Men
      • Recharge Program For Men
      • BioGroHair® Restoration Consultations
      • Bio ‘O’™ Libido Enhancement
    • Cancer Patient Support
    • Autism Support
  • BREAST HEALTH CLINIC
    • Breast Thermography
    • Breast Health Consultations
    • Breast Nutricheck
  • MEDIA/ARTICLES
    • Scientific Articles
    • Blog
    • Videos
    • Podcasts
    • Press
    • Testimonials
      • Breast Health
      • Cancer Patient Support
      • Hormones
      • Hair Restoration
      • General
    • Research
  • FEES
  • SHOP
  • CONTACT
    • Find Us
    • Make an Enquiry
  •  
The Uncomfortable Truth About Mammography

The uncomfortable truth about mammography, By Dr. EcclesBlog


Avatar for The Natural Doctor
02 Mar 2018 by Dr. Nyjon Eccles in Breast Health

By Dr Nyjon K Eccles BSc MBBS MRCP PhD

Opinion has been split for some time on the future of mammography as a reliable method of screening for breast cancer.

Some countries remain committed to the process, others are in the process of reviewing the arguments for and against and others, like Switzerland, have already begun to phase it out of their systematic diagnostic strategies.

One of the more obvious and well-publicised arguments against mammography, and one I have addressed regularly in these blogs and in the public events I speak at, is that it isn’t sufficiently accurate. Up to 60 per cent of all mammograms return an inaccurate diagnosis.

Although diagnostic accuracy is not the main subject of this article, I recommend that all women everywhere read this short but invaluable article on mammography from the famous Cochrane Foundation.

What that means in practice is that either the screening fails to identify the presence of a tumour and so appropriate treatment is delayed; or it wrongly diagnoses the presence of cancer, leading to inappropriate treatment being given.

That, of course, is reason enough to question its role as the sole diagnostic method supported by the NHS and cancer charities and I have called long and hard for additional screening methods, such as breast thermography, to be offered alongside mammography as part of a suite of diagnostic options from which women can choose.

However, there is another uncomfortable truth about mammography which is less well-publicised, and that is the pain that many women endure during the screening process.

As any woman who has undergone mammography will know, the process involves sandwiching the breast tissue between two plates to reduce its thickness. Understandably, given the maximum pressure applied can be up to 20kg, that can cause a degree of discomfort. This, it’s argued, is necessary to produce a clearer image.

Quite how much discomfort or outright pain women experience during screening is hard to quantify since the various studies carried out to date have defined pain in different ways. Depending on what study you read, it’s high as 93 per cent and as low as 1 per cent.

The fluctuation in figures notwithstanding, what those figures do prove is that all women will feel some degree of pain at some stage during the various mammograms they will undergo through the years.

Practitioners and supporters of mammography argue that any pain or discomfort is fleeting and that the benefit of having a clearer image as a result mitigates the unpleasantness. It’s an argument that might fly if mammograms were resolutely accurate all of the time, but rings a little hollow when you remember the process is inaccurate in up to 40 per cent of cases.

There are a number of issues that need to be addressed here.

One is that the physical trauma to tissue that mammography causes is a risk in itself. There’s a good deal of research that shows mammography can cause internal bruising, damage implants, cause clotting and accelerate the development of any tumour that may be present.

Another issue is that no-shows for screening appointments in the UK are much higher than is desirable, and that begs the question of why any woman would choose to stay away from a free screening that, even at current accuracy levels, has a chance of saving her life.

In many cases, it’s doubtless a time factor. We’re busy people and rescheduling what is, in the end, a routine appointment doesn’t seem like a particularly big deal.

But it’s entirely possible that the discomfort women endure is also part of the lower attendance levels. It’s the same reason many people avoid going to see their dentist – it’s going to be uncomfortable, so we put it off until another day.

The final issue is why women suffer in silence, and this is where I think the fundamental argument for additional options lies.

Those women who do attend their screenings endure the discomfort without publicly-recognised complaint because they know that mammography is currently the only option they will be given to find out whether they have or don’t have breast cancer. And until they have greater choice, they believe they must simply put up with the pain if they want the peace of mind that screening can bring.

There is a better, less traumatic way to identify breast cancer risk. But until we have a more open dialogue about the shortcomings of mammography, it will only be an option at clinics like ours.

The non-invasive, ThermoCheck breast thermography screening we offer is between 90 per cent and 95 per cent accurate (depending on the temperature of the breast tissue at the moment the thermal image is taken).

It identifies abnormal heat patterns in breast tissue, which can be an early indication of cancer risk, and is able to detect that risk up to ten years earlier than a mammogram can pick up a tumour – allowing you to adopt any lifestyle and nutritional changes that can prevent the disease.

You can find out more about ThermoCheck here. You can get details of the breast nutricheck test we offer to gauge general breast health.

BOOK AN APPOINTMENTFEES
0
Recommend
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • LinkedIN
  • Pinterest
Share
Tagged in

Contact Us

    Recent Post

    We’re having the wrong conversation about breast cancer prevention
    We’re having the wrong conversation about breast cancer prevention
    Dr. Nyjon Eccles
    Why the HRT Taskforce has failed all women
    Why the HRT Taskforce has failed all women
    Dr. Nyjon Eccles
    Why bioidentical hormone replacement therapy could save lives
    Why bioidentical hormone replacement therapy could save lives
    Dr. Nyjon Eccles
    Why we need an alternative to mammography for breast cancer screening
    Why we need an alternative to mammography for breast cancer screening
    Dr. Nyjon Eccles
    Testimonial from Jennie
    Testimonial from Jennie
    Dr. Nyjon Eccles

    Follow us

    NAVIGATE

    • About
    • Services
    • Testimonials
    • Recent Articles
    • Contact Us
    • Privacy
    • T&Cs
    Google Rating
    4.9
    The Natural Doctor
    The Natural Doctor
    4.9
    Ros
    Ros
    16:57 08 Feb 20
    I had some treatment for a breast condition in the clinic, people are very polite and nice including the doctors. I had to stop the treatment as It was not working but that's fair enough as no everything works for everybody. I stop going to the clinic and nobody in the clinic contacted me to find out what was going on, what happened with me. That showsed lack of care and I was disappointed about that.
    Alison Kittle
    Alison Kittle
    14:33 14 Aug 19
    Been visiting this clinic for nearly 10 years. It reassures me about my breast health and if I raise any concerns they are always answered well. Staff are professional but friendly. Dr Eccles knows his field. Will keep returning for my check ups. Peace of mind is worth so much.
    maria
    maria
    13:27 16 Jul 19
    For several years I have been seeing Dc Eccles for general l wellbeing. After I started seeing him, I felt much better. Excellent Doctor with very good supplements and product. I highly recommend Dr Eccles and his prescription.
    Anwen Pragnell
    Anwen Pragnell
    14:50 20 Jun 19
    A recent breast health scare in my 30's lead me to seek a less invasive option to check breast health. The Thermocheck scan, detailed report and Skype consultation with Dr Eccles was very professional and reassuring. I now feel more informed and supported in preparation for my hospital appointment. I highly recommend Dr Eccles and his team to provide an efficient, professional service and support your health naturally.
    Arthur Moore
    Arthur Moore
    09:27 16 Jan 18
    Thank you for giving me the opportunity to use your excellent product. Although it has only been 2 weeks, both myself and my wife have noticed, the hair growth has certainly become thicker, more of a covering. This is very encouraging, following many years of not really being bothered about my hair loss, now that I am noticing an improvement I am very excited at the prospects of once again having a full head of hair.
    Victoria Harris
    Victoria Harris
    09:54 12 Aug 20
    A very friendly but professional service. Experts in their field that go over and above to ensure you have the best service and experience.Highly recommend.
    Janie Wolf
    Janie Wolf
    09:06 31 May 22
    Dr Eccles has given me my life back, because he has balanced my hormones in a way that enables me to live my life to the full again!I was not only suffering with menopause fatigue and the many other symptoms of menopause, but I had ongoing lethargy with Auto-Immune Hashimotos and a struggling thyroid. It came to the point I didn’t know which symptom was due to which hormone deficiency.After my second thorough consultation with Dr Eccles, he had tweaked my dose and found I was indeed Iodine deficient. Now I am beginning to have normal levels of energy again and it is getting better and better, for the first time in five years! I sleep like a baby and my overactive bladder has been calmed. I am so glad I found Dr Eccles, life is too short to suffer with debilitating symptoms, he is the best doctor for me!
    Muxloe Property
    Muxloe Property
    19:48 17 Jun 22
    The Dr helped me feel like myself again after lots of low level symptoms. My GP dismissed me. It was worth every penny. Thank you
    Nicky Emlick
    Nicky Emlick
    21:19 23 Feb 22
    Highly recommend this practice. My experience so far after taking the thermogenic breast scan, and Bio identical hormone replacements has been a very pleasant and informative process.
    Crazy T
    Crazy T
    10:06 27 Oct 21
    I started seeing Dr Eccles almost 3 years ago for fertility issue , after struggling for 9 years and 2 miscarriages 2 years a part .I had done blood test with them and was on natural hormonal medication for almost 2 years ,and it worked for me and i fell pregnant and i have a 5 month old son now .I am still seeing him for general health and hopefully working towards second pregnancy.He is amazing , listens to every concern and answer all queries very nicely and in friendly manner and girls at receptions are also great and quick at responding to any questions or concerns i might have.
    Kelly Hafner
    Kelly Hafner
    15:58 09 Sep 21
    I began to see Dr Eccles six years ago and he continues to provide excellent care and attention every time I see him. I have referred several friends to him and they have all been very happy. Both Dr Eccles and his staff genuinely care and always go the extra mile. I highly recommend him for all areas of female health, immunity and healthy ageing in general!
    See All Reviews
    powered by Google

    FOLLOW

    SIGN UP

    © 2023 All Rights Reserved. The Natural Doctor is a Limited Company. Company Reg. No: 07360121. VAT No: GB282855959 | website by FOME

    The Natural Doctor
    Go to mobile version
    BOOK ONLINE